Not a bad shoe
I have wider feet. I wear a 10.5 or so in the Evolv Defy, so I ordered these in 11.5. On first wear they were painful in the toes to where I could only have them on for a few minutes. After a few uses, I've gotten used to the toe area, but the heel still digs into the back of my ankle. I can't really walk in them much yet. If they stretch just a touch more and the ankle wears in I think the fit will be good.
On the wall, I don't really notice the discomfort. These grip small edges well. I haven't been able to smear as well as in my less aggressive shoes.