Do a decent enough job
- Familiarity: I've used it several times
- Fit: Runs small
- Size Bought: L
Have worn them 3x now, in both cold (32F) or very wet (43F) conditions without fenders. Paired with a toe warmer on top of my shoe, my feet tolerated the weather in both types of conditions. For cold, the potential drawback is there is not bottom sole (so that it can accommodate MTB/Gravel shoes) so the bottom of your feet may get cold. For wet, even though it's a pretty tight fit at the top, I think water still finds a way in when there is a consistent wet road spray. Finally, I had to size up. Started with a M for my size 41.5 road shoes/42 MTB shoes. The road shoes barely fit but I couldn't get my MTB shoes on. With a size L it's still tight but I can get them on.
In the end, I think it's a good value for what you get. For longer rides in inclement weather, I would recommend want something extra to help these, like fenders or a toe warmer.