Black Diamond Spotter Long-Sleeve Shirt - Women's
Black DiamondSpotter Long-Sleeve Shirt - Women's

  • Reviews
  • Q & A

Poor Quality, Does Not Hold Up Over Time

  • Familiarity: I've put it through the wringer
  • Fit: Runs large
  • Size Bought: XS

I bought two of these shirts about 9.5 months ago in two colors, nickel black/gingham (XS) and merlot/captain gingham (S). I've worn them consistently since then. Unfortunately, after 6 months both shirts began to pill pretty terribly, and at 8 months some of the seams started unraveling, and both shirts began falling apart. I only washed them on delicate cycles with cold water, and hung them to dry. I did not climb in them, I used them as casual shirts for work. For such an expensive shirt, I really expected more, and now I can't wear either of them due to busted seams around the cuffs, sleeves, and sides, and terrible fabric covered in pills. For the record, both of the shirts are very loose on me, so stretching/pulling fabric should not be an issue that would cause seams to unravel. I too loved these shirts at first, but now I cannot recommend them to anyone.

Convinced this is the only shirt I need

  • Familiarity: I've used it several times
  • Fit: True to size
  • Size Bought: Small

Super soft and comfy. Great for cragging, couching, and drinking. Really well fitted. Getting flannels that fit my shoulders has really been an issue but this is really well fit. Fitted well on the shoulders and loose in the arms, allows for great movement. Only problem I see is that the fabric pills fairly quickly. It seems very durable though.

Can I live in this Shirt Forever?

  • Familiarity: I've used it several times
  • Fit: True to size
  • Size Bought: XS

Incredibly soft, well-constructed. Superior quality. It fits well around the shoulders, and then falls loosely away from there. So it's fitted around the shoulders and arms, but gives lots of room for movement and climbing.