It's not a 5-star because it's not warm enough for REALLY cold days, the cut is kind of blocky - not fitted at all - and the hood refuses to stay put so I can see when I'm shoveling snow or otherwise very active (there's no draw string so it can't be tightened). That said, the "stretchdown" fabric really works well, I like that it's less bulky under the arms, and just believe it's an all-round good everyday jacket, easily layered underneath . The M might be a little large on my frame, I didn't get the S because I feared on me I'd not be able to layer it. On sale it's worth every penny. I'm keeping it.

Absolutely LOVE this jacket. It's warm but lightweight and moving around is easy because of the stretchdown construction. It's also great looking. Probably not heavy enough for super cold days, but I want to wear it as often as possible. I'm 5'7" and around 160 and ordered a size medium - fits perfectly, not too bulky, and enough room to wear a sweater or sweatshirt underneath.